I’ve used this for years and it’s ALL I use to take off my eye makeup! It works great on waterproof mascara/eyeliner! It is oil based so that’s what helps with the stubborn eye makeup. If you don’t prefer that, then this particular product isn’t for you. I would compare it to Mary Kay’s makeup remover (oil based). But less expensive. I would highly recommend!
Almay products are usually mild, but this eye makeup remover is anything BUT gentle. After using it before going to bed, the next day my eyelids were bright red where product was applied. I believe it's a dangerous product.