I think I an 8.5 would fit me better. I usually wear a nine but can fit 8.5 sometimes. However, this shoe is wide. It doesn't hug the foot at all. It's a bit floppy. I wear a medium. I have athletic legs. I only paid $12 for these so I will probably keep them and wear them with pants but the sizing is definitely off. If you wear a size 9.5- or even a 10. The width is definitely wide width. The area that hits the ankle in front is also a little stiff. They are a great value on sale if they fit you - I like the low heel a lot because I am already 5'8" - but this would fit wider feet and thicker ankles better I think. The look and style is very cute.
Cute but runs big. I wear a size 9 or 10 depending on the brand. I ordered a size 9 online and they are too loose around the top and ankle. I’m afraid though that if I get a size 8.5 that my toes will stick off the shoes length wise. Going to return.
Very tight strap are not adjustable, over all love theses shoe! I just need to try and fix them some how.